Mystery Team

Donald Glover Jason Rogers Aubrey Plaza Kelly Peters Dominic Dierkes Charlie Day D.C. Pierson Duncan Wheeler Matt Walsh Jim Glenn Kalison Robert Peter Saati Leroy Kay Cannon Destiny Bobby Moynihan Jordy John Lutz Frank Robbie Sublett Ricky Appleman Tom Shillue Alan McGinty Ellie Kemper Jamie Kevin Brown Bouncer Dan Eckman Bread Squeezer Will Hines Mr. Stevens Meggie McFadden Cathy Kristopher Kling Sam Ben Schwartz Dougie's Buddy Ron Simons Mr. Rogers Nick Packard Dougie Daphne Ciccarelle Brianna Gregory Burke Football Player Jon Daly Greg Joe James Security Guard (uncredited)