Peder Stu

Mark Wahlberg Father Stuart 'Stu' Long Mel Gibson Bill Long Jacki Weaver Kathleen Long Teresa Ruiz Carmen Malcolm McDowell Monsignor Kelly Annet Mahendru Mary Cody Fern Priest Winter Ave Zoli Allison Faith Jefferies Time Keeper Ronnie Gene Blevins Bartender Ned Bellamy Dr. Novack Michael Fairman Randall Niko Nicotera Barfly Alain Uy Tim Carlos Leal Father Garcia Annie Lee Dr. Wan Aaron Moten Ham Molly Baker Mrs. Ferris Chiquita Fuller Waitress Betsy Moore Montana Sheriff Tenz McCall Young Stu Penny L. Moore Jenny Tim Sitarz Bouncer Rudy Moreno Market Customer Nicholas A. Goldreich Los Angeles Police Officer Indie DesRoches Sunday School Boy Lily Villegas Sunday School Girl Roberto Montesinos Carmen's Dad Danielle Golden EMT Sharmila Devar Los Angeles Nurse Sean O'Reilly Father Kelly's Secretary James Flavin Bishop Jorge-Luis Pallo Gael Clay Wilcox AA Chairperson Lila Karp-Ziring Medieval Background Girl Steve Olson Medieval Set Assistant Director Dennis Keiffer Medieval Bad Guy Travis Wong Medieval Knight Bryan Kreutz Bar Patron Larry Bagby Bartender Mathew Trent Hunnicutt Bar Patron Mariah Maison Cute Big Sky Nurse Tyler Burke 21 year old Kid Skip Howland Boxing Judge Pablo Ramos Church Parishioner Brian Ortega Boxer #2 Patricia Belcher Maude Colleen Camp Motel Receptionist Jack Kehler Curtis James Hunter Church Parishioner (uncredited) Alan Bagh Joe Seminarian (uncredited)